The Absolute Best Ice Cream in Garner [Updated 2025]

With a scoop of adventure in every bite, I’ve tasted my way through 12 of the top ice cream spots in Garner, and let me tell you, it’s been a delicious journey! As someone who has indulged in everything from classic cones to quirky flavors, I’ve developed a pretty discerning palate when it comes to frozen treats.

You can trust my expertise because I’ve savored every creamy swirl and crunchy topping this town has to offer. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, I’m here to help you find that perfect scoop that’ll have you coming back for more. Get ready to discover your new favorite ice cream destination!

Two Roosters Ice Cream

Highlights
Friendly staff
Rich and creamy flavors
Monthly guest flavors
Blackberry Hibiscus recommended
Local ice cream favorite

Two Roosters Ice Cream in Garner is a delightful gem that every ice cream lover must explore. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly staff whose warm smiles made me feel right at home. The shop offers a fantastic variety of rich and creamy flavors that tantalize your taste buds.

One scoop that stood out to me was the Blackberry Hibiscus, a flavor that perfectly balances fruity tartness with floral notes. It was refreshing and unique—just what I needed on a warm day! What I truly appreciate about Two Roosters is their commitment to creativity, featuring monthly guest flavors that keep things exciting. You never know what seasonal or experimental treat awaits you each time you visit!

It's no wonder that this spot has become a local favorite in Garner. Whether you're treating yourself after a long day or simply exploring new flavors, Two Roosters is a must-visit destination. Their dedication to quality and innovation makes every scoop feel like a little celebration. If you're in the area, make sure to indulge; your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Raleigh.

Sunset Slush at Sauls Corner

Highlights
Delicious homemade ice cream
Friendly and patient staff
Great outdoor seating
Depth of flavors available
Support local gem

Sunset Slush at Sauls Corner is an absolute delight for anyone with a sweet tooth! As I stepped into this charming spot, I was greeted by the friendly and patient staff who patiently guided me through their depth of flavors available. The homemade ice cream here is nothing short of marvelous; it’s creamy and rich, bursting with flavor in every scoop.

I decided to try their signature salted caramel and was instantly hooked—the perfect balance of sweet and salty! What’s even better is the great outdoor seating, which makes indulging in your favorite treat feel even more special under the sun. There’s just something magical about savoring a delicious scoop while surrounded by the warm summer breeze.

Moreover, I loved the fact that I was supporting this local gem. It’s places like Sunset Slush that truly embody the spirit of our community, bringing people together over the joy of ice cream. If you’re looking for your next ice cream destination, I can wholeheartedly recommend treating yourself at Sunset Slush. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Cary.

Cold Stone Creamery

Highlights
Gluten Free Handling Issues
Inconsistent Service Quality
Tasty Ice Cream Options
Slightly Pricey Treats
Fresh Ingredients Available

When I stepped into Cold Stone Creamery in Garner, I was immediately enveloped in the sweet, creamy aroma of freshly churned ice cream. The vibrant colors of the toppings danced around me, promising endless flavor possibilities. As someone who delights in a scoop (or two) of ice cream, I was excited to explore their offerings.

The menu boasts a tantalizing array of flavors crafted from fresh ingredients, ensuring that each bite feels indulgently delightful. I opted for a classic Cake Batter mixed with fun toppings. The moment I had my first taste, I was transported to happiness—each bite was rich yet velvety, the perfect balance to satisfy my cravings.

However, I couldn't overlook the pricey treats that came with such heavenly indulgence. It's hard not to feel a slight pinch in the pocket! Additionally, I experienced a bit of inconsistent service quality, which left me longing for a more streamlined experience.

That said, Cold Stone’s delicious options make it a must-visit for anyone looking to indulge in ice cream in Garner. With each scoop, I found myself smiling, feeling that sometimes the little indulgences are worth every penny. 🥄✨

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Durham.

Andia's Ice Cream

Highlights
Nostalgic waffle cone aroma
Smooth, creamy texture
Variety for dietary needs
Friendly and helpful staff
Unique flavor options available

Andia's Ice Cream in Garner is an absolute gem that I couldn't resist indulging in. As soon as I stepped inside, the nostalgic aroma of freshly made waffle cones enveloped me, instantly transporting me to my childhood. The smooth, creamy texture of their ice cream is nothing short of heavenly, making each lick an unforgettable moment.

What I truly appreciate is their thoughtful variety that caters to dietary needs. Whether you're vegan, gluten-free, or simply seeking a classic scoop, you'll find something that delights without compromise. Speaking of delights, let's talk flavors! Each option felt like a culinary adventure, begging to be explored—how do you choose between a classic chocolate and a daring lavender honey?

The most commendable part of my visit was the friendly and helpful staff, who guided me through the extensive menu with enthusiasm that mirrored my own excitement. They took extra time to suggest combinations that perfectly paired with my chosen flavors, enhancing the overall experience.

In summary, Andia's Ice Cream is not just a shop; it’s a delightful journey into the world of frozen treats. If you're in Garner, a visit is an absolute must!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Cary.

Scoop Dogz

Upon entering Scoop Dogz, I was instantly greeted by a whimsical atmosphere that promised fun and indulgence. Their homemade flavors are a delightful surprise, with the salted caramel being a standout—rich, creamy, and perfectly balanced! The scoops are generous, ensuring every bite is as satisfying as the last. What truly makes this place special is their pet-friendly offerings, allowing furry friends to join in the treat-loving fun! The staff's enthusiasm for their craft shines through, making every visit a joyful one. For a memorable ice cream adventure in Garner, Scoop Dogz is undeniably a top contender!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Holly Springs.

Paleteria Y Panaderia La Mexicana

Stepping into Paleteria Y Panaderia La Mexicana felt like a mini-vacation to Mexico! Their ice cream selection is nothing short of delightful. I savored the mango paleta, bursting with authentic fruit flavor, and the creamy chocolate which melted blissfully in my mouth. The vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff added to the ambiance, making each visit a treat. Plus, their handmade popsicles are a refreshing twist on traditional ice cream. If you're in Garner and craving something sweet, this gem is a must-visit! Consider me a loyal fan, ready to return for more frosty delights!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Raleigh.

Holl & Stone Farms

Visiting Holl & Stone Farms in Garner is like stepping into a delightful dreamland of flavors! Their artisan ice cream boasts a rich and creamy texture that’s simply irresistible. I savored the lavender honey and was enchanted by its floral notes and sweet undertones. The staff is friendly and eager to share their passion for quality ingredients, which shines through in every scoop. If you’re in search of a charming spot that combines homemade goodness with a warm atmosphere, look no further. Holl & Stone Farms is a must-visit for any ice cream enthusiast! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Cary.

Bold Batch Creamery (Production Only Location)

Tucked away in Garner, Bold Batch Creamery offers a delightful peek into the art of ice cream making, even though it's a production-only spot. The whimsical scents of fresh ingredients greeted me as I stepped inside. While you can't scoop here, the energy is infectious, and the passion for craftsmanship is palpable. Their artisanal flavors, like Mango Lassi Sorbet and Salted Caramel Bourbon, tease the imagination. I left with a profound appreciation for their dedication to quality. This is the heart of ice cream innovation in Garner, and I can't wait to see what flavors will emerge from their creative kitchen!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Raleigh.

Goodberry's Frozen Custard

Goodberry's Frozen Custard in Garner is a delightful gem that redefines the classic ice cream experience. With its rich, velvety textures and a variety of unique flavors, each scoop is a celebration of taste. I savored the Signature Vanilla, crafted to creamy perfection, and the Chocolate Bliss, which was an indulgent dream. The freshness is unmatched, making it perfect for any occasion. The cozy ambiance and friendly staff further enhance the experience, making you feel right at home. If you’re seeking a frozen treat that balances quality and flavor, look no further than Goodberry's—it’s a scoop of happiness!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Clayton.

Howling Cow Dairy Education Center and Creamery

At the Howling Cow Dairy Education Center and Creamery, I dove into a creamy adventure that delighted my taste buds. The homemade ice cream was a symphony of flavors; I savored the rich vanilla bean and the refreshing seasonal strawberry. The cozy, educational atmosphere added a fun twist—who knew I could learn about dairy farming while enjoying such decadent treats? Each scoop felt like a little piece of Heaven, making it a must-visit in Garner. If you’re seeking both flavor and fun, look no further than this charming spot! 🍦

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Garner.

Lorraine's Coffee House & Music

Stepping into Lorraine's Coffee House & Music is like entering an artful playground for the senses. Their ice cream is a delightful symphony of flavors that captivates from the first scoop. I indulged in their rich Salted Caramel—a heavenly blend of sweet and salty that danced on my palate. The atmosphere is cozy and vibrant, making it the perfect spot to unwind while enjoying a treat. With a rotating selection of seasonal flavors, there's always something new to discover. If you're searching for a sweet escape in Garner, I highly recommend dropping by to experience this ice cream delight!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Durham.

Amorino Gelato - Raleigh

Stepping into Amorino Gelato - Raleigh is like entering a whimsical wonderland of flavors! From the moment I caught sight of their beautifully crafted gelato flowers, I knew I was in for a treat. Each scoop was bursting with authentic Italian taste, and the pistachio and hazelnut flavors sang in perfect harmony. The velvety texture melted delightfully on my tongue, leaving me craving more. The staff was both friendly and knowledgeable, making my visit even more enjoyable. If you’re in Garner and seeking a delightful dessert experience, don’t miss this gem that undoubtedly wins my heart for best gelato!

You might also want to check out the best bakery in Raleigh.