The Absolute Best Ice Cream in Cary [Updated 2025]

After countless scoops and delightful taste tests, I’ve narrowed it down to 12 incredible spots that serve up the creamiest, most delectable ice cream in town. As someone who thrives on flavor exploration and has spent years indulging my sweet tooth in Cary, I promise you’ll find your next favorite treat right here.

Whether you’re a fan of rich chocolate, fruity sorbets, or unique artisanal flavors, I’ve tasted it all and gathered my top picks just for you. Trust me, when it comes to ice cream, I don’t settle for anything less than extraordinary, and I can’t wait for you to dive into this creamy adventure with me!

Andia's Ice Cream

Highlights
Unique and underrated flavors
Phenomenal coffee bean crunch
Perfect balance of flavors
Quick and kind service
Excellent allergy handling

Review of Andia's Ice Cream in Cary

During my latest ice cream quest in Cary, I stumbled upon Andia's Ice Cream, and it turned out to be a delightful surprise! My taste buds were immediately intrigued by their range of unique and underrated flavors. One scoop of the phenomenal coffee bean crunch was enough to whisk me away to my happy place. Each bite was a delicious blend of rich coffee, complemented perfectly by the satisfying crunch that kept the experience exciting.

What truly impressed me was the perfect balance of flavors in every scoop. Whether I was indulging in a classic or exploring a more adventurous option, it was evident that each recipe had been carefully crafted. The staff was not only quick but incredibly kind, making my visit a joyous occasion.

Given my penchant for seeking ice cream that caters to all, I also appreciated their excellent allergy handling—a considerate touch that allows everyone to enjoy their treats without worry. If you find yourself in Cary and craving a sweet escape, Andia’s is undeniably one of the best places to indulge in some delightful ice cream!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Raleigh.

FRESH. Local Ice Cream

Highlights
Creamy, delicious flavors
Generous portion sizes
Friendly, patient staff
Variety of unique options
Great location near park

At FRESH. Local Ice Cream, I was immediately drawn in by the delightful atmosphere. The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a friendly staff that exuded warmth and was eager to help me navigate their impressive array of flavors. The variety is truly a standout feature; while classics like vanilla and chocolate are present, the unique options like lavender honey and blackberry basil really caught my eye.

I opted for a scoop of the lavender honey and a generous portion honestly took me by surprise. Each spoonful was a creamy, dreamy adventure, as the sweet floral notes danced on my taste buds. What’s more, the ice cream had this remarkable balance of flavors that made it impossible to resist having another bite. When I finished, I had yet again to remind myself — portion control!

The location itself is perfect, nestled near a lovely park, making it a great stop for a post-picnic treat. In sum, FRESH. Local Ice Cream is a must-visit for anyone in Cary looking to indulge in something truly special. If you haven’t tried it yet, do yourself a favor and head there soon!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Durham.

Geluna Gelato

Highlights
Constantly rotating flavors
Classic and new options
Friendly, knowledgeable staff
Great overall experience
Must-try frozen treats

Geluna Gelato is truly a gem in Cary's bustling ice cream scene! Upon stepping inside, I was greeted by the friendly staff, who exuded a passion for their craft. It's evident they take pride in their constantly rotating flavors, making every visit a delightful challenge—what to choose from such an array of classic and innovative options?

On my latest visit, I indulged in their lavender honey gelato, a whimsical blend that danced on my palate with a soft floral note, while the creaminess offered a luxurious mouthfeel. I was also tempted by their dark chocolate sorbet—an intense burst of cocoa that made my taste buds sing. Each scoop showcases exceptional quality, with ingredients crafted to evoke the essence of their flavors.

The ambiance is wonderfully inviting, making it an ideal spot for both a casual treat or a special outing. What sets Geluna apart is not just their incredible gelato, but the overall experience. If you're searching for a place where flavor dreams come true, Geluna Gelato should be at the top of your list! With must-try frozen treats and warm smiles, it's hard not to leave with a grin and a new favorite.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Raleigh.

Vida Dulce

Highlights
Friendly and clean establishment
Great for families and kids
Colorful and vibrant atmosphere
Delicious desserts available
Spacious area for play

Vida Dulce is a delightful gem in Cary that really knows how to whip up an unforgettable dessert experience! From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a friendly staff and an atmosphere that radiated joy. The establishment is not only clean, but it also features a colorful decor that instantly lifts your spirits—perfect for families and kids seeking a sweet escape.

Now, let’s talk about the ice cream. The flavors are a true testament to creativity, and they showcase a vibrant array of deliciousness. I couldn’t resist trying a scoop of their signature vanilla bean, a classic refined to perfection. With its creamy texture and rich flavor, it simply melted in my mouth, transcending the ordinary!

Beyond the heavenly ice cream, I noticed the availability of various desserts that tantalized my taste buds. The spacious area allows for both intimate outings and playful family gatherings. In fact, it’s a fantastic place to let kids roam free while indulging in a tasty treat! Overall, Vida Dulce not only serves stellar ice cream but also creates an ambiance that leaves you smiling long after you’ve finished your cone. 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Cary.

Honeysuckle Gelato Fenton

Highlights
Friendly and helpful staff
Delicious banana pudding flavor
Authentic cinnamon roll taste
Amazing chocolate and peanut butter
Charming outdoor seating area

Upon entering Honeysuckle Gelato Fenton, I was greeted by the friendly and helpful staff who instantly made me feel welcome. With an extensive menu that would tempt anyone’s palate, I was excited to embark on my frozen adventure.

I couldn’t resist trying their delicious banana pudding flavor, which was a delightful blend of creamy sweetness and nostalgic flavor. It transported me back to summer picnics with every spoonful! But the true star of my tasting experience was the authentic cinnamon roll taste—a marvel of chilly indulgence that captured the essence of a fresh-baked treat.

I also sampled their amazing chocolate and peanut butter, a dynamic duo that danced beautifully on the taste buds, making it impossible to not go back for more.

The ambiance was equally inviting, with a charming outdoor seating area that offered the perfect backdrop for savoring these delights.

In conclusion, Honeysuckle Gelato Fenton is a gem in Cary's ice cream scene that not only serves unforgettable flavors but also creates a delightful experience. For anyone in search of the best ice cream, this spot deserves a top recommendation.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Raleigh.

Two Roosters Ice Cream

Highlights
Cute and modern shop
Delicious, unique flavors
Thicker texture, less melting
Great outdoor seating
Recommended ice cream flight

Review of Two Roosters Ice Cream in Cary

Nestled in the heart of Cary, Two Roosters Ice Cream offers a delightful escape filled with whimsical flavors and charming decor. As I entered this adorable shop, I was immediately captivated by its modern vibe, creating an inviting atmosphere that beckons ice cream lovers of all ages.

The real showstopper, however, is the exceptional flavor selection. From the moment I laid eyes on their menu, I was amazed by the unique combinations that dance together beautifully. My personal favorites? The lavender honey and the Mason Jar Pie—a heavenly blend of textures and tastes that felt both nostalgic and innovative.

One standout feature I appreciated was the thicker texture of the ice cream, which meant I could savor each spoonful without worrying about a puddle forming too quickly. Pair that with the great outdoor seating area, and you have the perfect spot for a sunny day indulgence.

For the indecisive foodies like myself, I highly recommend their ice cream flight—a delightful way to sample multiple flavors and find your new go-to scoop. Two Roosters Ice Cream is a must-visit for anyone craving an indulgent, fun-filled ice cream experience in Cary!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Clayton.

MilkShake Factory Cary

At MilkShake Factory Cary, the moment I walked in, I was greeted by the delightful scent of freshly made waffle cones. Their menu boasts a tantalizing array of milkshakes and ice cream that tempt the senses. I indulged in the Salted Caramel Pretzel shake—an extravagant blend of sweet and salty that left me craving more with each sip. The creamy texture and rich flavors are a testament to their craft. The vibrant atmosphere is perfect for families or a casual outing with friends. If you’re in Cary, don’t miss this gem for a delightful ice cream adventure!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Garner.

Sugar Koi

Sugar Koi is a delightful gem nestled in Cary, and it truly knows how to charm your taste buds! As I stepped inside, the vibrant decor radiated a playful vibe that immediately lifted my spirits. Their unique flavor combinations are a standout; I sampled the mango sticky rice—a creamy masterpiece that danced on my palate with hints of sweet coconut and subtle warmth. The texture was divine, velvety smooth and utterly indulgent. Don’t skip the waffle cones; they’re freshly made and pair perfectly with each scoop. For a fun ice cream adventure in Cary, Sugar Koi is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Durham.

Goodberry's Frozen Custard

Goodberry's Frozen Custard truly captivates with its creamy, rich textures and a menu brimming with exciting flavors. I was immediately drawn to their signature Vanilla custard, which is luxuriously smooth and balanced perfectly with a hint of sweetness. The famous Concrete mixes here are a delightful adventure—topped with my choice of fresh fruit and candy, it's a colorful explosion of taste!

I particularly loved how every cone feels like a personalized masterpiece. If you’re in Cary, Goodberry's is a must-visit—your taste buds will thank you for this culinary delight!

You might also want to check out the best bakery in Raleigh.

MILKLAB

Stepping into MILKLAB felt like entering an ice cream wonderland! Their artisanal approach sets them apart, with flavors that are both inventive and classic. I indulged in the Lavender Honey, a delightful blend that danced on my taste buds, followed by a scoop of their rich Salted Caramel—pure bliss! The cozy atmosphere made every lick even more enjoyable, supported by friendly staff eager to offer recommendations. If you’re searching for a truly unique ice cream experience, MILKLAB is not to be missed. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Raleigh.

JT's Creamery - Holly Springs

JT's Creamery – Holly Springs is a delightful gem that truly captures the spirit of summer all year round. The moment I stepped inside, the playful aroma of freshly churned ice cream enveloped me, inviting me to explore their irresistible flavors. I opted for the Salted Caramel Pretzel, which was a heavenly blend of sweet and salty — a textural delight! Each creamy bite had me dreaming of beach days. The staff was as friendly as a warm sunny afternoon, making the experience even sweeter. If you’re seeking a scoop of happiness, JT’s is a must-visit in Cary! 🍦✨

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Raleigh.

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

Nestled in the heart of Cary, Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams is a delightful oasis for dessert lovers. From the moment I walked in, the vibrant atmosphere and unique flavors ignited my excitement. The Salted Peanut Butter with Chocolate Flecks was a heavenly blend of sweet and salty, while the Brown Butter Almond Brittle offered a luxurious crunch. Each scoop is crafted with care, showcasing Jeni's dedication to high-quality ingredients. If you're chasing creamy, adventurous treats, Jeni's is a must-visit. This spot is not just ice cream; it’s an experience that invites you to indulge your sweet tooth with exuberance!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Chapel Hill.