The Absolute Best Bagels in Cary [Updated 2025]

Each bagel shop has its own unique charm, and trust me, I’ve savored every last crumb from twelve of the top spots around town. Whether you're a classic plain bagel lover or someone who craves adventurous flavors, I’ve got the scoop on where to find the most delicious bites in Cary.

As someone who’s spent countless mornings chasing the perfect schmear and sharing laughs with local bakers, I’m here to guide you through the tastiest options. Get ready to discover where to find that perfect balance of chewy and crispy because your next favorite bagel is just a bite away!

New York Bagel & Deli

Highlights
Incredible bagels
Efficient and friendly service
Reminiscent of Northeast bagels
Delicious cheesecake
Popular destination for bagel lovers

New York Bagel & Deli has quickly become a favorite spot of mine, and for good reason! As soon as you step inside, you're greeted with an aroma that instantly transports you to the bustling streets of the Northeast—a true bagel lover's paradise. Their bagels are nothing short of incredible; each one is perfectly boiled and baked to achieve that glorious golden crust. From the classic everything bagel to unique flavors, every bite bursts with flavor.

What really sets this place apart, however, is the efficient and friendly service. The staff members genuinely seem to love what they do, making customers feel welcome, which is always a plus! And don’t skip on dessert; their rich and creamy cheesecake is an absolute delight that has me dreaming of my next visit.

This establishment isn’t just a place to grab a quick breakfast; it’s a popular destination for bagel enthusiasts looking to satisfy their cravings. New York Bagel & Deli has truly mastered the art of the bagel, delivering a taste that reminds you of a classic New York deli right here in Cary. If you haven't stopped by yet, you're missing out on something special!

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Raleigh.

Big Dom's Bagel Shop

Highlights
Best Montreal style bagels
Perfectly crisp and soft
Friendly and helpful staff
Popular weekend destination
Great breakfast to go options

Visiting Big Dom's Bagel Shop was akin to stepping into a cozy corner of Montreal without leaving Cary. The moment I walked in, I was greeted by an enthusiastic team that truly understands the art of bagel-making. What struck me most was their perfectly crisp and soft Montreal-style bagels that practically begged to be devoured.

As I savored my first bite, the flavor explosion was nothing short of delightful; each bagel had that wonderful chewy texture that I absolutely adore. The bagels here are never dull, with offerings that can easily elevate your breakfast routine. Whether you’re on the go or enjoying breakfast at their small seating area, Big Dom’s is an incredibly popular weekend destination, drawing in fellow bagel enthusiasts.

I also appreciated the helpful staff who guided me through their menu, suggesting the best combinations for a truly memorable meal. If you’re in Cary and searching for bagels that can satisfy your cravings in a fun, welcoming atmosphere, look no further than Big Dom's. This shop has undoubtedly secured a spot in my heart — and my list of Cary’s best bagels! 🎉🥯

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Durham.

Esteamed Coffee

Highlights
Exceptional customer service
Cozy atmosphere with ample seating
Fast service even during busy hours
Good selection of baked goods
Community-oriented workplace skills

Esteamed Coffee has a delightful charm that draws you in the moment you enter. The cozy atmosphere is inviting, complete with ample seating, perfect for settling in with a fresh cup of coffee and a bagel. The exceptional customer service is evident from the moment you're greeted with a warm smile, making your experience even more enjoyable.

Now, let’s talk about their bagels. Esteamed Coffee offers a solid selection, complemented by an array of spreads that elevate each bite. My bagel was toasted to perfection—crispy on the outside and soft on the inside, a textural triumph! Every bite was a celebration of flavors, marrying the doughy goodness with the rich, creamy toppings.

What impresses me is how they manage to maintain fast service, even during busy hours, which speaks volumes about their efficiency. It’s not merely a coffee shop; Esteamed doubles as a community hub, showcasing a passion for both coffee and baked goods. If you're in Cary and looking for your next bagel adventure, Esteamed Coffee is a joyful stop. With a perfect blend of quality and community spirit, I can't recommend it enough!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Raleigh.

Great Harvest Bread Co - Cary

Highlights
Fresh baked bread options
Friendly and helpful staff
Great indoor and outdoor seating
Seasonal and unique treats
Best Irish soda bread

At Great Harvest Bread Co - Cary, the aroma of freshly baked bread welcomes you like a warm hug on a chilly morning. With a menu that tantalizes both the traditional and adventurous palate, this bakery isn’t just about standard bagels. Their assortment features an array of seasonal and unique treats that set them apart in the Cary bagel scene.

The staff here is as friendly as they come, always ready with a smile and an enthusiastic recommendation. I found myself chuckling as they cheerfully suggested pairing their signature bagel flavors with creative spreads - definitely an up-sell worth indulging in! The best Irish soda bread I’ve ever tasted was a delightful bonus to my visit, showcasing their commitment to quality baking.

From the spacious indoor seating to the inviting outdoor area, Great Harvest is a perfect spot for both a casual breakfast or a lively catch-up with friends. Whether you dive into a classic bagel or explore one of their daring seasonal flavors, this bakery undoubtedly serves up some of the most delightful bagels in Cary. If you haven’t made a trip yet, it’s time to put on those walking shoes and treat yourself!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Cary.

NYC Bagels

Nestled in the heart of Cary, NYC Bagels is a delightful gem that brings a splash of New York to the Triangle. As I stepped inside, the warm aroma of freshly baked bagels wrapped around me like a cozy blanket. I indulged in their everything bagel, topped with a rich cream cheese that could make anyone swoon. Each bite was a perfect balance of chewy and crispy, striking that elusive harmony. The staff's friendliness is the cherry on top, making it feel like a genuine neighborhood spot. If you’re in Cary and crave a taste of the Big Apple, don’t miss this crowd-pleaser!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Raleigh.

La Farm Bakery

La Farm Bakery is a delightful gem in Cary, where I discovered bagels that are the perfect blend of chewy and flavorful. Each bite transports you to a realm of authenticity, reminiscent of New York's finest. I sampled the "Everything" bagel, topped with a generous crunch of seasonings—it was a true taste sensation! The warm, inviting atmosphere of the bakery made for a cozy experience, complemented by their exceptional coffee. I couldn’t resist grabbing a cheese-filled deli sandwich as well, which was just as delightful. If you’re in search of bagel bliss, La Farm should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Clayton.

Bruegger's Bagels

Nestled in the heart of Cary, Bruegger's Bagels is a delightful haven for bagel enthusiasts. As I stepped inside, the aroma of freshly baked bagels wrapped around me like a warm hug. The everything bagel I sampled was a true masterpiece—crispy on the outside, soft and chewy within. The bold flavors of the toppings enhanced the experience, especially with a generous smear of their creamy cream cheese. The staff were welcoming, adding a dash of friendliness to my visit. If you're on the hunt for quality bagels, Bruegger's is a must-try destination in Cary!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Garner.

NC Bagel Cafe' & Deli

At NC Bagel Cafe' & Deli, each bite is a delightful adventure! The sesame seed bagel was impeccably fresh, boasting a perfect crust-to-chew ratio. They offer a wide range of spreads, but the cream cheese with chives stood out, adding a burst of flavor that made it irresistible. The ambience is cozy, ideal for lounging with a warm cup of coffee. I left feeling satisfied and eager to return—a true testament to their bagel artistry. For anyone in Cary with a bagel craving, this place is an absolute gem worth visiting!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Durham.

New York Bagels & Deli Raleigh

As I stepped into New York Bagels & Deli Raleigh, the aroma of freshly baked bagels enveloped me like a warm hug. Their everything bagel was a marvelous blend of pop and crunch, topped generously with seeds that danced on my taste buds. I paired it with their homemade scallion cream cheese, which was so creamy, it could win awards! The friendly staff adds to the charm, making every visit feel like a special occasion. With each bite, I felt transported straight to a bustling New York deli. This gem in Cary guarantees a bagel experience that’s nothing short of extraordinary.

You might also want to check out the best bakery in Raleigh.

Benchwarmers Bagels

Benchwarmers Bagels is a delightful gem that brings joy to every bagel lover's heart. Upon entering, the aroma of freshly baked bagels wraps around you like a warm hug. I was particularly enchanted by their everything bagel, which featured a perfect blend of flavors—crisp yet chewy, a true bagel lover's dream. The scallion cream cheese added a delightful zing that elevated the entire experience. The staff were friendly, eager to share recommendations that felt genuinely thoughtful. For an unforgettable bagel experience, Benchwarmers is undoubtedly a place where you can warm your heart and indulge your taste buds!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Raleigh.

Chanticleer Cafe & Bakery

Nestled in the heart of Cary, Chanticleer Cafe & Bakery is a delightful gem that crafts exceptional bagels. With a warm, inviting atmosphere, this cafe offers a variety of flavors that tantalize the taste buds. I indulged in their everything bagel, perfectly toasted, with a luscious smear of cream cheese that was rich yet light. The balance of seasonings was spot on, creating a bagel experience that's hard to forget. The friendly staff added a personal touch, making every visit feel special. If you're on a quest for the best bagels in Cary, Chanticleer is a must-try!

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Raleigh.

Pineapple Sol Cafe

Pineapple Sol Cafe offers a delightful twist on the classic bagel experience. Their Everything Bagel bursts with flavor, topped with the perfect blend of seasonings that dance on your palate. The texture is spot on—crispy on the outside, yet soft and chewy within. I indulged in their signature cream cheese spread, flavored with fresh herbs, enhancing the overall experience. The cozy atmosphere makes it a perfect spot to enjoy a leisurely breakfast. If you’re hunting for a bagel that feels like a mini vacation, Pineapple Sol should definitely be on your list! 🌺🥯

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Chapel Hill.