The Absolute Best Pie in Cary [Updated 2025]

Over the past few weeks, I’ve embarked on a delicious adventure, sampling pies from twelve of the most talked-about spots in Cary. Trust me, this wasn’t just a sweet indulgence; it was a quest fueled by my passion for uncovering local treasures and my unwavering belief that pie is one of life’s greatest joys.

As someone who takes pie seriously—whether it’s a classic slice or a daring flavor mash-up—I’ve developed a discerning palate that’s been shaped by countless tastings and a few less-than-stellar experiences. You’re not just getting my opinion; you’re getting the result of my pie-loving heart and a commitment to finding the best that Cary has to offer. So, grab your fork and let’s dive into this mouthwatering journey!

Once In A Blue Moon Bakery & Cafe

Highlights
Friendly and efficient staff
Quick turnaround times
Custom cake options available
Gorgeous and delicious designs
Highly recommended by customers

Once In A Blue Moon Bakery & Cafe truly captured my heart—and my taste buds! The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the friendly and efficient staff who made me feel right at home. Their enthusiasm was infectious, which made my pie selection even more delightful.

I decided to try their signature pie, and oh my goodness, it was a masterpiece. With a gorgeous design that looked like it was crafted by a pastry artist, the first bite whisked me away to a state of bliss. The flavor was the perfect balance of sweet and tart, leaving me wanting more long after I savored the last slice.

What stood out to me was the quick turnaround time; I didn’t have to wait long to indulge in this delicious creation. Plus, the option for custom cakes is an exciting perk for special occasions! It’s no wonder they come highly recommended by customers. If you're in Cary and craving an unforgettable pie experience, Once In A Blue Moon Bakery & Cafe is the place to be. I can’t wait to return for more!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Cary.

Asali Desserts & Cafe

Highlights
Cozy and inviting atmosphere
Exceptional coffee offerings
Friendly and attentive service
Unique dessert options
Cool and modern decor

At Asali Desserts & Cafe, stepping through the door feels like wrapping yourself in a warm, sweet hug. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, making it the perfect spot to indulge in delightful desserts. As I scanned the menu, I couldn't resist the urge to try their renowned pie offerings.

The unique dessert options here are a delightful melody of flavors, and their signature pie was nothing short of a culinary masterpiece. The crust was flaky and buttery, encasing a filling that sang with just the right amount of sweetness. Each bite was a perfect blend of textures and tastes that left me craving more.

The friendly staff were quick to recommend pairing my pie with a cup of their exceptional coffee, which elevated the experience to new heights. As I savored my dessert, I couldn’t help but admire the cool and modern decor that enveloped me, further enhancing the experience.

If you’re in Cary and on a quest for the best pie, make your way to Asali Desserts & Cafe—it’s a delightfully sweet journey you won’t want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best food trucks in Raleigh.

Cary Sweets

Highlights
Great selection and service
Best pastries in town
Beautifully presented sweets
Halal bakery option
Nostalgic flavors

Cary Sweets: A Slice Above the Rest

During my latest quest for the finest pie in Cary, I stumbled upon Cary Sweets, a delightful bakery that tantalizes the senses in more ways than one. As soon as I walked in, I was embraced by the warm aroma of baked goods, showcasing a great selection that immediately sparked my excitement.

The star of my visit, of course, was the pie—an indulgent offering that was not only beautifully presented but also a true testament to the craftsmanship of the bakers. I opted for a nostalgic apple pie, an absolute classic. The flaky crust encased the tender, cinnamon-spiced apples, making each bite a joyful reminiscence of simpler times.

One of the most delightful aspects of Cary Sweets is their welcoming staff, who provide superb service and are eager to recommend their best pastries. Moreover, they offer Halal options, catering to a diverse clientele.

In conclusion, if you find yourself in Cary, be sure to swing by Cary Sweets. Whether you're seeking a slice of nostalgia or simply a moment of bliss in pie form, this bakery delivers an experience that satisfies all cravings!

You might also want to check out the best food trucks in Durham.

Great Harvest Bread Co - Cary

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming staff
Fresh baked bread options
Great seasonal items
Ideal for lunch and treats
Best Irish soda bread

Great Harvest Bread Co - Cary is a delightful destination for pie lovers seeking a unique twist on the traditional. Upon entering, I was immediately embraced by the warm, welcoming atmosphere and the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked bread. The staff was not just friendly; they felt like old friends eager to share their passion for baked goods.

While their signature pies receive high praise, I found myself captivated by their seasonal offerings, especially the autumn-inspired pumpkin pie that exuded warmth and nostalgia. With each slice, I discovered a harmonious blend of spices and sweetness, perfectly complemented by a flaky crust that practically melted in my mouth.

What truly sets Great Harvest apart, though, is their commitment to using high-quality ingredients. You can taste the freshness in every bite, which is a rare find in the pie world. Their selection of fresh-baked breads, including the popular Irish soda bread, makes it impossible to leave empty-handed.

If you're looking for a slice of happiness in Cary, make your way to Great Harvest Bread Co. Your taste buds will thank you, and you just might discover your new favorite pie!

You might also want to check out the best food trucks in Cary.

Baghdad Bakery & Market أفران و أسواق بغداد

Highlights
Exceptional customer service
Family-owned and operated
High-quality Iraqi bread
Welcoming and friendly atmosphere
Clean and well-maintained store

Baghdad Bakery & Market أفران و أسواق بغداد is a hidden gem that surprised me with its delightful offerings. From the moment I stepped inside, the welcoming atmosphere wrapped around me like a warm hug, thanks to the exceptional customer service provided by the friendly staff. It's charming to see a family-owned business where the passion for quality shines through every corner of the establishment.

Now, let's talk about the highlight — the pastries! The Iraqi bread was a revelation; its texture and flavor are out of this world! I couldn’t resist trying their sweet pastries, which are meticulously crafted to perfection. Each bite was a playful dance of flavors that left my taste buds craving more. The clean and well-maintained store speaks volumes about their dedication to both quality and customer experience.

Overall, Baghdad Bakery is a slice of culinary heaven in Cary. If you’re on the hunt for traditional delights, look no further. Whether you're stopping by for a simple loaf of bread or indulging in their delicious pies, this bakery is sure to leave you smiling and satisfied. Don't miss out on this local treasure — your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Raleigh.

Cinnaholic

Highlights
Vegan dessert options
Variety of baked goods
Complaints about quality
Raw cookie inside
Difficulty reaching staff

Cinnaholic in Cary certainly puts an interesting twist on classic desserts, though calling it a pie place might be a bit of a stretch! Entering the charming café, the aroma of warm cinnamon rolls and baked goods wafts through the air, inviting you to explore their unique offerings.

During my visit, I couldn't resist diving into their vegan cinnamon roll, but let’s just say this was not your typical pie experience. The roll boasted an impressive variety of toppings, which was a fun surprise. However, I must admit, I encountered a few hiccups. The raw cookie dough filling was a bit unexpected, and the texture was not quite what I would have hoped for in a perfect dessert.

Moreover, I faced a challenge attempting to reach the staff for assistance, which dampened my experience slightly. While I appreciate their commitment to vegan desserts and the inventiveness on display, the quality didn't quite meet my expectations. In all honesty, if you're hunting for pie in Cary, you might want to explore other options! But for a whimsical treat, Cinnaholic could still delight the adventurous dessert lover.

You might also want to check out the best bloody mary in Durham.

Groovy Duck Bakery

Highlights
Amazing themed cakes
Delicious soft cookies
Quality ingredients used
Super sweet, accommodating staff
Worth the commute

If you’re on the hunt for a pie that’s sure to delight, Groovy Duck Bakery in Cary is an absolute gem that you won’t want to miss! Nestled in this vibrant community, I was welcomed by a warm and friendly atmosphere, courtesy of the super sweet, accommodating staff who are eager to share their passion for baked goods.

As I approached the counter, the display was irresistible, with amazing themed cakes vying for my attention, but it was the heavenly pies that really captured my heart. Each slice showcases the use of quality ingredients, promising not just taste but also a wholesome experience. The crust was perfectly flaky, a delightful contrast to the luscious, flavorful filling that danced on my palate.

While I must admit the delicious soft cookies also caught my eye, I was there for the pie experience, and Groovy Duck certainly delivered. It’s clear that this bakery is worth any commute, offering a slice of happiness with every bite. If you’re craving deliciousness in your dessert, remember, Groovy Duck Bakery isn’t just a stop—it’s a pie adventure!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Raleigh.

Craft Public House

Highlights
Excellent service
Generous dessert portions
Vast menu options
Clean and well-kept
Good for group dining

Craft Public House is a delightful gem in Cary, and trust me, their pie is nothing short of a revelation. Upon entering, I was greeted with excellent service that instantly put me in the mood for a sweet treat. The atmosphere is both cozy and vibrant, perfect for unwinding after a long day or gathering with friends.

Now, let's get to the star of the show: the pie! I indulged in their signature dessert, and let me tell you, the generous dessert portions did not disappoint. The crust was perfectly flaky, holding a treasure trove of luscious filling that danced with flavors. As I savored each bite, I couldn't help but appreciate the commitment to quality found in their kitchen.

What’s more, the menu boasts vast options, making it hard to choose just one pie! From traditional flavors to inventive combinations, there’s something to please every palate. The clean and well-kept space adds to the overall enjoyable experience, making Craft Public House an ideal spot for group dining as well.

If you’re searching for a slice of happiness in Cary, I urge you to visit Craft Public House – you won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Cary.

La Farm Bakery

At La Farm Bakery, I discovered a delightful slice of pie that dances on the palate. Their seasonal fruit pie burst with flavors straight from the orchard, beautifully harmonizing sweetness with a flaky, buttery crust. Each bite felt like a warm hug, reminding me of classic homemade goodness. The vibrant colors and textures make this pie not just a treat for the taste buds but also a feast for the eyes! If you crave a slice of nostalgia, look no further than La Farm Bakery for a pie that truly defines deliciousness in Cary. 🍰 Exceptional.

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Raleigh.

Chanticleer Cafe & Bakery

During my visit to Chanticleer Cafe & Bakery, I was immediately enchanted by the cozy atmosphere and warm smiles. Their signature pie, a luscious berry medley, was a burst of flavors that danced on my palate. The flaky crust was the perfect vessel, showcasing the sweet-tart berries in delightful harmony. Each bite felt like a warm embrace, and I couldn't resist going back for seconds! The attentive staff added to the charm, making me feel right at home. If you're in Cary and craving a slice of happiness, look no further than Chanticleer—it's a pie lover's paradise!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Clayton.

Annelore's German Bakery

At Annelore's German Bakery, I savored their exquisite Black Forest Pie, a delightful fusion of luscious chocolate and cherry flavors that whisked me away to dessert heaven. The crust was perfectly flaky, embodying that homemade touch, while the creamy filling danced on my palate. Each bite was a celebration of German tradition, showcasing the bakery's commitment to quality. The cozy ambiance and welcoming staff made my visit even more enjoyable. If you’re in Cary and craving a slice of bliss, Annelore's is a must-try. Trust me, you won’t leave without a smile—or a second slice!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Garner.

Brecotea

At Brecotea, the pie selection dazzles with its vibrant flavors and charming presentation. I savored the blueberry pie, which was bursting with juicy berries and perfectly balanced sweetness—an homage to summer in every bite. The flaky crust was a masterpiece, complementing the filling beautifully. Equally impressive was the inviting atmosphere, making it a delightful spot for pie enthusiasts. Their signature matcha latte was the perfect companion, enhancing the overall experience. If you're in Cary and seeking a slice of happiness, Brecotea is a must-visit destination for pie lovers!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Durham.