The Absolute Best Bagels in Garner [Updated 2025]

With a passion for food that rivals my love for coffee, I dove headfirst into the bagel scene here in Garner, sampling everything from classic plain to the most adventurous flavors. Trust me, it’s been a delicious adventure! After reviewing 12 top locations, I’ve gathered the scoop on which bagels are truly worth your time—and your taste buds.

You might wonder why you should trust my findings. Well, I’m not just a casual observer; I’ve savored every bite, chatted with the bakers, and even picked up a few insider tips along the way. So, whether you’re a lifelong local or just passing through, let’s embark on this flavorful journey together!

The Muse Coffee Company & Roastery

Highlights
Adorable and cozy atmosphere
Great coffee and breakfast options
Wonderful warm smiling service
Perfect ambiance with classic music
Patient staff during busy times

Review of The Muse Coffee Company & Roastery

Stepping inside The Muse Coffee Company & Roastery felt like being wrapped in a warm, cozy hug. This charming little spot boasts an adorable atmosphere with its mismatched furniture and soothing playlist of classic tunes. As I settled in, I was greeted by the wonderful warm smiles of the staff, who are as patient as they are friendly, even during the busy morning rush.

Now, let's talk bagels! Their bagels are a delightful surprise—not only do they beautifully complement the artisanal coffee, but they also stand out on their own. I savored a perfectly toasted everything bagel, topped generously with cream cheese. Each bite was a heavenly union of crispiness and chewiness, making it clear that they pay close attention to detail here.

The Muse offers a variety of breakfast options, making it a great stop for anyone looking to fuel their day. If you’re like me and enjoy fantastic coffee with your bagels, you won’t be disappointed. All in all, The Muse is a gem in Garner, and I’ll definitely be back to explore more of their menu. Don’t snooze—this coffee and bagel hub is worth a visit!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Cary.

Benchwarmers Bagels

Highlights
Quaint and beautiful atmosphere
Huge and delicious bagels
Notable butterscotch coffee
Very high expectations
Disappointment with bagel quality

Benchwarmers Bagels in Garner had me excited from the moment I stepped inside. With its quaint and beautiful atmosphere, I felt welcomed and eager to indulge in a bagel feast. The aroma of freshly baked goods filled the air, tantalizing my taste buds almost immediately. However, as I eagerly scanned their vast menu, my high expectations were set.

I decided to try one of their huge and delicious bagels, anticipating it to be an unforgettable experience. Unfortunately, I was met with a hint of disappointment as the bagel fell short of my lofty hopes. While it looked impressive, the taste didn't quite match the visuals—leaving me longing for that perfect chewiness and flavor burst that bagels are known for.

On a brighter note, I savored a cup of their notable butterscotch coffee, which was a delightful companion to my meal. While the bagels may not have hit the mark for me, this charming café still offers a cozy environment worth visiting. I may not be rushing back for bagels, but I’d gladly return for that heavenly coffee and the lovely ambiance. So, if you’re ever in Garner, do keep Benchwarmers on your list!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Raleigh.

New York Bagel & Deli

Highlights
Long lines, great food
Northeast-style bagels
Efficient and friendly service
Excellent cheesecake available
Variety of tempting treats

New York Bagel & Deli in Garner is a delightful gem that pays homage to the classic Northeast-style bagels. On my visit, I was greeted by a long line— a sure sign of something special. The aroma of freshly baked bagels wafted through the air, teasing my taste buds and foreshadowing the culinary delights that awaited.

The service was not only efficient but friendly, making the wait all the more enjoyable. As I finally approached the counter, I couldn’t resist opting for the everything bagel, topped with a generous spread of cream cheese. Oh, what a treat! It had that perfect chewy texture with a crisp, golden crust— a true representative of bagel perfection.

As I indulged in my bagel, I also noticed their mouthwatering cheesecake displayed nearby, which I simply had to try. It was rich, creamy, and not overly sweet— just the way I like it.

All in all, New York Bagel & Deli offers not just fantastic bagels but a full experience that leaves you satisfied and eager to return. If you’re ever in Garner and craving a true bagel fix, this place is a must-visit!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Cary.

Full Bloom Coffee Roasters

Visiting Full Bloom Coffee Roasters in Garner is like stepping into a warm embrace of flavors. Their bagels are delightfully chewy with a perfect crust, and each bite bursts with freshness. The everything bagel truly shines, topped with a medley of seasonings that dance on your palate. Paired with a rich coffee, it’s a match made in breakfast heaven. The cozy atmosphere invites you to linger, whether you’re a bagel aficionado or just in search of a tasty treat. If you're in Garner, don’t miss out—this spot might just become your new favorite bagel haven!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Raleigh.

Eggs Up Grill

At Eggs Up Grill, I discovered a delightful twist on the classic bagel. Their everything bagel was a beautiful blend of flavor, topped generously with cream cheese that boasted a creamy richness. The lively atmosphere and friendly staff only added to the enjoyment. What truly stood out was the option to customize your bagel sandwich, turning breakfast into a playful experience. The crunchy exterior and soft interior made each bite an absolute joy. If you find yourself craving a bagel fix in Garner, Eggs Up Grill is a must-visit for a scrumptious treat that will keep you coming back for more!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Clayton.

Aversboro Coffee

Tucked away in a cozy corner, Aversboro Coffee serves up not just exceptional brews but also delightful bagels that elevate your morning routine. The everything bagel is a standout, boasting a perfectly toasted exterior while the inside remains chewy and fresh. Topped with a generous spread of cream cheese, each bite is a satisfying blend of flavors. The atmosphere is inviting, making it a perfect spot to linger or grab a quick bite. Whether you’re stopping by for a caffeine boost or a bagel fix, Aversboro is definitely a must-visit for bagel enthusiasts in Garner!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Garner.

Nana's Lil Sweets

At Nana's Lil Sweets, the bagels are a delightful surprise! Each bite is fluffy and flavorful, with a perfect balance of chewiness. I indulged in their everything bagel, topped with a generous spread of cream cheese that was simply divine. The warm, welcoming atmosphere reflects their commitment to quality and service. I could easily see myself enjoying one of these gems on a lazy Sunday morning! Overall, if you're on the hunt for a playful twist on the classic bagel experience, this charming spot should definitely be on your radar. Don't miss the chance to treat your taste buds!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Durham.

Morning Times

Stepping into Morning Times feels like a cozy hug on a plate. Their bagels? A delightful symphony of chewy perfection. I tried the everything bagel, perfectly toasted and topped with a generous spread of cream cheese that was smooth and rich. The contrasting flavors danced harmoniously, making each bite a treat for my taste buds. The atmosphere buzzed with friendly chatter, and the baristas crafted both coffee and smiles effortlessly. If you're hunting for bagel bliss in Garner, Morning Times should definitely be on your radar. Trust me, your breakfast will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best bakery in Raleigh.

Iris Coffee Lab

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Iris Coffee Lab in Garner, and let me tell you, their bagels are a delightful revelation! Nestled in a cozy corner, the atmosphere invites you to relax and indulge. I opted for their everything bagel, which boasted a perfectly crispy exterior and a chewy interior. Topped with a generous spread of herb cream cheese, it was an explosion of flavors in each bite. Their baristas are just as passionate about coffee as bagels, making it the ideal spot for a morning treat. If you’re in Garner, don’t miss this gem!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Raleigh.

New York Bagels & Deli Raleigh

Stepping into New York Bagels & Deli Raleigh in Garner felt like a delightful escape to the Big Apple! The aroma of freshly baked bagels instantly enveloped me, making it impossible to resist trying several varieties. Their everything bagel was a standout—crunchy on the outside yet soft and chewy within, perfectly complemented by rich cream cheese. The staff exuded friendliness that made my visit even more enjoyable. Each bite was a reminder of what a true bagel should be—simple yet satisfying. If you're hunting for a true bagel treasure, this spot should be at the top of your list!

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Raleigh.

The Left Hook Coffee Counter

At The Left Hook Coffee Counter, I was greeted by the aroma of freshly baked bagels that instantly beckoned my taste buds. Their everything bagel, perfectly toasted and generously topped, was a delightful explosion of flavors. Paired with a zesty cream cheese spread, it was a match made in breakfast heaven! The cozy atmosphere and friendly baristas added to the charm, making it a lovely spot to linger. If you're on the hunt for a bagel that hits all the right notes, look no further than this gem in Garner—it’s truly a must-try for any bagel enthusiast!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Chapel Hill.

Bad Cat Coffee, Crepes, & Bagel Sammiches

At Bad Cat Coffee, Crepes, & Bagel Sammiches, I discovered a delightful fusion of flavors that truly stands out. The bagels are lovingly crafted, boasting a chewy texture and a variety of creative toppings. I couldn't resist trying their signature Everything bagel topped with cream cheese and smoked salmon, which was an absolute delight! The ambiance radiates a cozy charm, making it the perfect spot to sip on coffee while indulging in a scrumptious bagel. Their passion for quality translates into every bite, making this gem a must-visit for bagel enthusiasts in Garner!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Wake Forest.