After devouring countless reubens from coast to coast, I’ve honed my palate to recognize the perfect blend of flavors and textures that make this classic sandwich shine. I’ve scoured Cary, NC, and reviewed twelve of the top spots, each with its own unique twist on this beloved dish. Trust me, I know a good reuben when I taste one, and I’m here to help you navigate this delicious journey.

Whether you’re a lifelong fan or a curious newcomer, I promise you’ll find some serious gems that will have you craving more. Get ready to embark on a mouthwatering adventure that will leave you with a newfound appreciation for the reuben—Cary style!

New York Bagel & Deli

Highlights
Authentic northeastern vibe
Friendly and efficient service
Incredible bagels
Great selection of treats
Delicious cheesecake

When I stepped into New York Bagel & Deli, I was immediately transported to the heart of New York City. The ambiance radiates an authentic northeastern vibe that’s as warm as the bagels fresh out of the oven. Their friendly and efficient service made my visit even more enjoyable as I eagerly anticipated my reuben sandwich.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show: the reuben. This sandwich is a delectable masterpiece. The corned beef is tender and packed with flavor, layered generously with tangy sauerkraut and melted Swiss cheese, all perfectly nestled between two slices of grilled rye bread that offered a lovely crunch. Every bite was a delicious blend of textures and tastes, leaving me craving more.

Also, it’s impossible to ignore their incredible bagels and fantastic selection of treats, which simply add to the charm of this deli. I couldn’t resist indulging in a slice of their delightful cheesecake afterward—an absolute must!

If you're on a quest for the best reuben sandwich in Cary, look no further than New York Bagel & Deli. This local gem serves up an irresistible experience that's worth every bite!

You might also want to check out the best reuben sandwich in Raleigh.

Great Harvest Bread Co - Cary

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming staff
Freshly baked bread varieties
Great spot for lunch
Seasonal and special items
Helpful with special requests

Great Harvest Bread Co – Cary: A Reuben Adventure

If you're hunting down the ultimate reuben sandwich, look no further than Great Harvest Bread Co - Cary. Nestled in a cozy corner, this establishment is a dieter's dream, boasting freshly baked bread that elevates each bite. As soon as I walked in, the welcoming staff greeted me with smiles that complemented the rich aroma of baking bread.

The reuben here is a must-try! Each sandwich is crafted with a generous layer of corned beef piled high, tangy sauerkraut, and a luscious slathering of house-made dressing. But what truly sets this sandwich apart is the artisanal bread, freshly baked that morning, providing a crisp exterior and a soft, pillowy interior that withstands the weight of its delicious filling.

And the best part? They’re more than willing to accommodate special requests! You can tweak your sandwich to perfection without a hint of hesitation from the staff. Whether dining with friends or grabbing a quick lunch, this place is more than just a bakery—it's a haven for reuben enthusiasts like myself.

In the quest for Cary’s best reuben, Great Harvest Bread Co certainly wins in my book!

You might also want to check out the best club sandwich in Raleigh.

Crosstown Pub & Grill

Highlights
Family-owned and operated
Cozy pub atmosphere
Lovely outside patio
Great menu variety
Landmark in downtown Cary

The moment I stepped into Crosstown Pub & Grill, I was enveloped by its cozy pub atmosphere, a delightful contrast to the hustle and bustle of downtown Cary. As a family-owned and operated establishment, you could feel the warmth and care permeating through both the service and ambience. I'm not just there for the ambiance, though; I'm on a quest for the ultimate reuben!

Their rendition of the classic reuben sandwich was nothing short of extraordinary. The rye bread was perfectly toasted, highlighted by a satisfying crunch that gave way to tender layers of corned beef and tangy sauerkraut. The balance of flavors—savory, spicy, and sour—was enhanced further by a generous drizzle of creamy thousand island dressing. Every bite had me thinking I hit the jackpot!

And let’s not forget the lovely outside patio, perfect for enjoying your meal when the weather is right. With such an impressive menu variety, Crosstown has officially carved out its spot as a must-visit for reuben lovers. If you find yourself in Cary, this gem is an absolute must-try on your culinary journey!

You might also want to check out the best club sandwich in Durham.

The Parkway Tavern

Highlights
Late-night food options
Fast and friendly service
Amazing onion rings
Hidden gem in Cary
Great menu variety

At The Parkway Tavern, I found more than just a satisfying late-night haunt; I discovered a delightful twist on the classic Reuben sandwich. Nestled in this cozy spot, the atmosphere buzzes with an inviting energy that makes you feel right at home. The service was impressively swift and friendly, enhancing the overall enjoyment of my visit.

Now, onto the star of the show: the Reuben itself. This masterpiece features perfectly toasted marble rye that cradles generous layers of tender corned beef, gooey Swiss cheese, and tangy sauerkraut, all slathered with a rich, homemade dressing that elevates each bite. The key balance of flavors danced delightfully on my palate, making it a sandwich worth savoring.

Beyond the amazing Reuben, I couldn’t resist indulging in their incredible onion rings—a crunchy accompaniment that might just steal a bit of the focus away from the sandwich. With a diverse menu that caters to various cravings, The Parkway Tavern truly is a hidden gem in Cary. If you find yourself in the area, don’t miss out on the chance to indulge in their wondrous Reuben—it’s a delightful culinary adventure that will leave you coming back for more!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Raleigh.

BottleDog Bites & Brews

Highlights
Quaint and quiet atmosphere
Friendly and attentive staff
Delicious food options
Great for hosting events
Dog-friendly dining experience

BottleDog Bites & Brews has quickly become a delightful gem in Cary, and I was eager to see if their reuben could live up to the hype. As soon as I stepped inside, I was greeted with a quaint and quiet atmosphere that felt just right for a casual lunch. The inviting space, complemented by its dog-friendly vibe, was the perfect setting for a relaxing meal.

The staff were exceptionally friendly and attentive, making sure my dining experience was nothing short of excellent. Now, let's talk about the star of the show—the reuben sandwich. It's a beautiful creation, with perfectly marbled corned beef, topped generously with tangy sauerkraut and melted Swiss cheese, all nestled between two slices of toasted rye bread. Each bite was a delightful explosion of flavor that had me savoring every moment.

What really stood out, though, was their commitment to quality. The reuben was not just delicious; it felt like a labor of love. Whether you're stopping by for a quick bite or hosting an event, BottleDog is a must-visit for anyone craving a stellar reuben experience in Cary!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Cary.

Spirits Pub & Grub

Highlights
Beautiful outdoor patio
Dog-friendly atmosphere
Excellent craft beer selection
Great service by staff
Appealing location near downtown

At Spirits Pub & Grub, I was immediately struck by their beautiful outdoor patio. It's a delightful setting that offers a welcoming atmosphere, especially for dog lovers like me—can we talk about dog-friendly dining? The ambiance is lively, yet relaxed, perfect for unwinding with good food and great company.

Now, let’s get to the star of the show: the reuben sandwich. I must say, it's a true gem! The corned beef was tender and perfectly seasoned, nestled between two robust slices of rye bread. Every bite was a delightful experience, thanks to the generous layers of sauerkraut and a creamy, zesty dressing that tied everything together beautifully. I also appreciated that the sandwich was grilled to a golden brown, giving it that irresistible crunch.

Adding to my joy was the excellent craft beer selection available, enhancing the meal’s experience. On top of all this, the service was top-tier; the staff genuinely made me feel at home. If you’re seeking the ultimate reuben sandwich in Cary, I highly recommend paying a visit to Spirits Pub & Grub—it’s well worth it!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Raleigh.

Brooklyn Pickle Raleigh

Brooklyn Pickle Raleigh has truly delighted my taste buds with their delectable reuben sandwich. This sandwich features generous layers of tender corned beef, perfectly melted Swiss cheese, and tangy sauerkraut, all embraced by toasted rye bread that is just the right amount of crisp. The magic lies in their homemade thousand island dressing, which elevates the entire ensemble. Each bite is a hearty celebration of flavors, making it hard to resist going back for more. If you're on the hunt for a reuben that packs a punch, Brooklyn Pickle offers a delightful experience you won’t want to miss!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Clayton.

Fratelli's Delicatessen

At Fratelli's Delicatessen, I was greeted by the mouthwatering aroma of sizzling corned beef and toasted rye. Their Reuben sandwich is a delightful balance of tender, flavorful meat, tangy sauerkraut, and creamy thousand island dressing—each bite a harmonious symphony! The bread, perfectly grilled to a crispy golden brown, held everything together beautifully. A generous portion left me both satisfied and ready for more. If you're on a quest for the ultimate reuben in Cary, Fratelli's is a delightful stop that deserves a place on your palate's map. Don't miss out on this gem—it's a riot of flavor!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Garner.

Serendipity Gourmet Deli

Serendipity Gourmet Deli captured my taste buds with their delectable reuben! Nestled in the heart of Cary, this gem serves up an expertly crafted sandwich, showcasing tender corned beef layered between toasted rye. The house-made sauerkraut adds a tangy crunch, perfectly complemented by a velvety swirl of thousand island dressing. Each bite is a savory delight that dances on the palate! I found the balance of flavors and textures to be truly delightful. If you’re in the mood for a reuben that delivers both quality and taste, look no further than Serendipity!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Durham.

Chanticleer Cafe & Bakery

At Chanticleer Cafe & Bakery, the reuben sandwich is a delightful surprise! Nestled between perfectly toasted rye, tender, house-made corned beef dances with layers of sauerkraut and a rich, creamy Thousand Island dressing. Each bite bursts with flavor, showcasing a masterful balance of tang and savoriness that keeps you reaching for more. The addition of melted Swiss cheese adds a decadent touch that elevates this classic. The cozy, inviting atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a relaxed lunch. If you're on the hunt for the best reuben in Cary, don’t miss this gem—it's a delicious delight!

You might also want to check out the best bakery in Raleigh.

Jason's Deli

The moment I stepped into Jason's Deli, the aroma of freshly baked rye whisked me away. Their reuben sandwich is a delightful masterpiece! The layers of succulent corned beef are perfectly complemented by tangy sauerkraut and a rich, creamy thousand island dressing. Each bite is a harmonious blend that dances on the palate. The generous portion size is perfect for hearty appetites, and the bread's crunch juxtaposes beautifully with the tender filling. If you're hunting for a satisfying reuben experience in Cary, look no further—Jason's Deli delivers a deliciously memorable sandwich that is sure to please!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Raleigh.

Craft Public House

At Craft Public House, the reuben sandwich is a delightful adventure! The house-made corned beef is tender and generously piled high, complemented by perfectly melted Swiss cheese. What truly sets this creation apart is the tangy house-made sauerkraut that adds a mouthwatering zing, all nestled between toasted marbled rye. The balance of flavors is simply exceptional. Paired with their crispy fries, this sandwich is a must-try for any reuben enthusiast. If you're on a quest for the best reuben in Cary, don’t miss out on this gem — it might just steal your heart (and taste buds)!

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Raleigh.