The Absolute Best Pies in Chapel Hill [Updated 2025]

You know that feeling when you take your first bite of a warm slice of pie, and it feels like a cozy hug from the inside? That’s exactly what I’ve been chasing as I explored twelve of the top pie spots around town. Trust me, I’ve tasted my way through countless crusts, fillings, and toppings to bring you the very best.

With a discerning palate honed by years of indulging in Chapel Hill’s culinary scene, I know the difference between a good pie and a truly unforgettable one. So grab your fork and let’s dive into this delicious journey together—you won’t want to miss these sweet (and savory) delights!

Even Dough Bakery - By Appointment Only

Highlights
Exceptional Customer Service
Delicious Vintage Cakes
Reasonable Pricing
Perfectly Soft Icing
Beautiful Presentation

Even Dough Bakery - By Appointment Only is a gem tucked away in the heart of Chapel Hill that demands your attention. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted with exceptional customer service that made me feel like I was part of the family. The ambiance is cozy and inviting, perfect for indulging in their delightful offerings.

As a pie aficionado, I couldn’t resist trying their selection. Each pie was a testament to both artistry and flavor, and I quickly discovered they also feature delicious vintage cakes that could rival any classic recipe. The beautiful presentation of each dessert added a visual feast to the already delightful experience.

What truly stood out to me was the perfectly soft icing, which elevated the whole experience, complimenting the pies in the most divine way. With such top-notch desserts at reasonable pricing, Even Dough pushes the envelope of what a bakery should be! If you’re seeking an experience where customer service and scrumptious sweets collide, I wholeheartedly recommend paying them a visit. Indulge in their offerings, and you might just find your new favorite pie in Chapel Hill!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Raleigh.

Alpha Pie

Highlights
Delicious pizza slices
Friendly and efficient service
High-quality ingredients
Variable cooking consistency
Unique ranch dressing

Alpha Pie is a hidden gem, nestled in the heart of Chapel Hill, where delicious memories are crafted one slice at a time. As I stepped inside, I was immediately greeted by the friendly and efficient service that sets this place apart. The staff seemed genuinely delighted to share their enthusiasm for pies.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show—the pizza slices. Each pie is a testament to the quality ingredients used. From the rich tomato sauce to the perfectly melted cheese, every bite was a delightful dance of flavors. I must note, however, that the cooking consistency can vary, which may leave you with a slice that’s either perfectly crispy or a tad softer than anticipated. It's all part of the whimsical charm that Alpha Pie offers.

And let me not forget the unique ranch dressing that accompanies the slices. It adds a fantastic twist that elevates the overall experience. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, take a moment to savor a slice at Alpha Pie—your taste buds will thank you for it!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Cary.

Mama Dip's Kitchen

Highlights
Rich family heritage
Friendly and attentive staff
Scrumptious chocolate pecan pie
Complimentary treats for guests
Clean and pleasant atmosphere

Mama Dip's Kitchen is an absolute gem tucked away in Chapel Hill, and it belongs on any pie-lover's radar. Stepping into the cozy atmosphere, I was instantly welcomed by the friendly and attentive staff who made sure I felt right at home. The rich family heritage here is palpable, with recipes passed down through generations and a sense of nostalgia that envelops the place.

Now, let’s talk about the pie—the scrumptious chocolate pecan pie is a standout. This delightful creation is a decadent marriage of silky chocolate and crunchy pecans, all ensconced in a perfectly flaky crust. Each bite is like a warm hug for your taste buds! What’s more, I was pleasantly surprised by the complimentary treats offered to guests, enhancing the overall experience—it's those little touches that make a visit truly special.

Whether you’re there for breakfast, lunch, or simply to indulge your sweet tooth, Mama Dip’s is a must-visit spot. With its clean surroundings and charming ambiance, you’ll not only savor a slice of pie but a piece of Southern hospitality along the way. Don’t miss this delicious destination in Chapel Hill!

You might also want to check out the best burgers in Raleigh.

Loaf

Highlights
Creative flavor combinations
Freshly baked each morning
Excellent ube coconut flan
Amazing cream puffs
Must-visit for pastry lovers

Loaf in Chapel Hill is an absolute treasure for anyone with a penchant for pastry. The moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by the tantalizing aroma of freshly baked goods wafting through the air. Each morning, the talented bakers whip up a melange of creative pie flavors that simply beckon you to indulge.

One standout is their ube coconut flan, which is a delightful fusion of textures and tastes that transports you straight to dessert heaven. It’s a fantastic twist that complements their traditional offerings beautifully. Additionally, the cream puffs are nothing short of magical—light and airy with a filling that is perfectly balanced, making them a must-try for any pastry lover.

Every pie I savored was a testament to the dedication and craft that goes into their baking. Loaf is not just another bakery; it’s a celebration of flavors and creativity. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, this charming spot deserves a top place on your culinary adventure list. If you're seeking an unforgettable pie experience, make Loaf your destination—your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Clayton.

The Phoenix Bakery

Highlights
Dill Cheese Biscuits Delight
Breakfast Sandwich Perfection
Life-Long Fan Status
Highly Recommended Breakfast

The Phoenix Bakery in Chapel Hill is a hidden gem that truly captured my heart—and my taste buds! What sets this charming spot apart isn’t just their mouthwatering pies but also their standout Dill Cheese Biscuits. These delightful morsels had me grinning from ear to ear and wondering how I would ever go back to a standard biscuit.

As I ventured further into their menu, I couldn't resist trying their Breakfast Sandwich, which was the perfect blend of flavors. The ingredients were fresh, and each bite felt like a cozy hug for my stomach. If breakfast items were eligible for a fan club, I'd definitely be a life-long member of The Phoenix Bakery.

Now, let’s talk pie! Their signature options showcase a remarkable balance of flavors, with the crust being flaky yet substantial. I relished every bite, savoring the delicate dance of sweetness. I highly recommend starting your day here—not just for the pies but for an unforgettable breakfast experience. If you happen to find yourself in Chapel Hill craving a delightful treat, make sure to pay a visit to The Phoenix Bakery. Your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Garner.

Ninth Street Bakery

Highlights
Delicious croissants
Spacious central space
Tasty homemade salads
Great coconut banana cake
Fair prices

Ninth Street Bakery is a delightful gem that captures the essence of what a local bakery should be. Stepping inside, I was immediately drawn to the spacious central space that exudes warmth and charm. The atmosphere was buzzing with the tantalizing aroma of fresh pastries; I could easily spend an afternoon here.

As I browsed their selection of delicious croissants, I couldn't resist the allure of their pies. Their signature fruit pies, brimming with seasonal ingredients, struck the perfect balance between sweetness and tartness. Each bite was a flavor explosion, showcasing the bakery's commitment to using high-quality, homemade ingredients.

While the pies were undeniably the highlight, I must mention their tasty homemade salads and a tempting coconut banana cake that beckoned from the display case. Perfectly rich yet not overly sweet, the cake was an unexpected treat that complemented my pie indulgence beautifully.

What truly stood out at Ninth Street Bakery was the fair pricing, making it accessible for everyone to enjoy a slice (or two) of pure happiness. If you’re seeking a place where both passion and craftsmanship shine through, look no further than Ninth Street Bakery for your next pie adventure!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Durham.

Breakaway Cafe

Highlights
Delicious avocado toast
Fast moving order line
Great coffee selection
Generous portions
Inviting patio seating

At Breakaway Cafe, my taste buds embarked on a delightful journey, giving me a chance to indulge in more than just their famed pies. The moment I walked in, the atmosphere was buzzing, yet I was pleasantly surprised by how rapidly the order line moved—a testament to their efficient service.

While I eagerly anticipated my pie, I couldn’t resist the temptation of their delicious avocado toast. It was bursting with flavor, ensuring I wouldn’t leave the cafe hungry. Speaking of portions, they are generous! Each dish is served with love, leaving you both satisfied and content.

Once my pie made its grand entrance, I couldn't help but admire the beautiful presentation. It was a perfect balance of flaky crust and luscious filling, capturing the essence of what a great pie should be. With a great coffee selection to wash it down, my experience at Breakaway was nothing short of spectacular.

The inviting patio seating made for a perfect setting to relish my pie, basking in the beautiful Chapel Hill weather. For anyone in search of deliciousness paired with a cozy vibe, Breakaway Cafe is a must-visit! Trust me, this gem is worth discovering.

You might also want to check out the best bakery in Raleigh.

Merritt's Grill

Highlights
Famous BLTs
Quick service
Reasonable prices
Quality outdoor seating
Delicious coconut cake

Review of Merritt's Grill

Stepping into Merritt's Grill is like entering a cozy slice of heaven. Hidden away in Chapel Hill, this gem is widely known beyond just its famous BLTs; the pie selection too deserves a standing ovation! While many flock here for their sandwiches, I found myself irresistibly drawn to the whims of dessert.

First things first, if you ever find yourself at Merritt's, you absolutely cannot miss their coconut cake. It’s a delightful ending that dances between sweet and creamy, leaving a lingering taste that’s simply unforgettable. But let's not sideline the pies. Their seasonal offerings can sweep you off your feet, framing the term "comfort food" in the most delicious way imaginable.

Aiming for convenience? The service is fast and friendly, ensuring that your cravings are swiftly satisfied. Plus, the outdoor seating area is an inviting escape—perfect for pie enthusiasts like myself looking to enjoy a slice while soaking up the Chapel Hill vibe.

In a town rich with culinary delights, Merritt's Grill stands out as a must-visit for anyone eager to indulge. With great prices and a warm atmosphere, it’s where pie lovers can really have their cake and eat it too!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Raleigh.

Guglhupf Bake Shop

At Guglhupf Bake Shop, I was greeted by an aromatic symphony of baked delights that enticed my taste buds. Their signature pie, the Buttermilk Cream Pie, is a delectable masterpiece—velvety smooth with a perfect hint of tang. The flaky crust cradles the filling with a delightful crunch, making each bite an exquisite experience. Additionally, the charming ambiance of the shop, adorned with European flair, invites a cozy escape. I left with a smile that only a perfect pie can inspire. If you're in Chapel Hill, don’t miss this gem where flavors dance in harmony!

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Raleigh.

Tonya's Cookies & Bake Shop

Tonya's Cookies & Bake Shop is a delightful hidden gem that captures the essence of homemade goodness. Their signature pecan pie is a true revelation—rich, nutty, and perfectly balanced with just the right amount of sweetness. The crust, buttery and flaky, cradles the filling like a warm hug. Each bite transports you to dessert heaven! A close second is the seasonal apple pie, bursting with tender apples and a hint of cinnamon that dances on your palate. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff add to the charm. If you're in Chapel Hill, this spot is a must-visit for pie lovers!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Chapel Hill.

Sweet Little Something

Sweet Little Something is a delightful gem in Chapel Hill that serves up a slice of pure joy. From the moment you step inside, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pies embraces you like a warm hug. I opted for their signature pecan pie, and it was nothing short of magnificent—a perfect balance of rich, nutty flavors and a smooth caramel finish. The buttery crust had a delicate flakiness that made each bite heavenly. The charming atmosphere and friendly staff only add to the experience. If you're seeking a slice of happiness, this is the place to visit! 🍰✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Wake Forest.

Whisk & Rye

At Whisk & Rye, I was greeted by the delightful aroma of freshly baked goods. The buttermilk pie was a revelation—silky and subtly tangy, it danced on my palate with each bite. The crust? A buttery masterpiece that crumbled delightfully. Their seasonal fruit pies also deserve praise; the strawberry-rhubarb combo was both sweet and tart, capturing the essence of spring. The cozy atmosphere made me want to linger, savoring every morsel. If you’re in Chapel Hill, don’t miss this gem; it’s where pie dreams come true, one slice at a time! 🍰✨

You might also want to check out the best hot dogs in Raleigh.